PDA

View Full Version : Why this sentence doesn't require a conjunction or a semicolon?


Victor
09-03-2009, 12:26 AM
The sentence: Can you tell me why I am so obsessed with you?

I wonder why this sentence does not require a conjunction or a semi-colon for being a valid sentence. As I know, a valid clause means that there are only one subject and one predicate (I actually see it as a verb instead, as a predicate must contain one). Now, I am seeing this sentence as two parts, two independent clauses:
1) Can you tell me why?
2) I am so obsessed with you.

Unless the word "why" could act as a conjunction, I really do not understand.

Recently, I am reinforcing the infrastructure of my English, so if my questions unfortunately seem too naive to you, please kindly pardon me, thanks and sorry.

By raising this query, I have encountered another doubt again... I wonder if it is valid to have two conjunctions to connect two independent clauses?
For instance:
Unless you forgive me, otherwise I am going to be very upset.

Thank you very much.

Marius Hancu
09-03-2009, 12:55 AM
The original sentence is correct.
See the equivalent:

Can you tell me the reason for which I am so obsessed with you?

Marius Hancu
09-03-2009, 12:58 AM
>Unless you forgive me, otherwise I am going to be very upset.

This is wrong. Try:

Unless you forgive me, I am going to be very upset.

Take
unless: except if

OddThomas
09-03-2009, 06:33 AM
Also, look at your sentence this way:Can you tell me [something]?
Something is the direct object of tell. And what is something?something = why I am so obsessed with you
Putting the parts together produces:Can you tell me why I am so obsessed with you?

Eddie88
09-03-2009, 02:50 PM
To add onto OT's point, the direct object is in the form of a noun clause.

Search this on google, and this may help to clear things up

Eddie88
09-03-2009, 02:53 PM
Unless you forgive me, otherwise I am going to be very upset.

Unless is a subordinator beginning a dependent clause (adverbial).

Otherwise is a conjunctive adverb--a word that cannot join two clauses by a comma--and a word that cannot join a dependent and main clause.

I will forgive you; otherwise, we will remain single.

I will forgive you. Otherwise, we will remain single.

If you don't forgive me, otherwisewe will remain single.

Victor
09-06-2009, 03:02 AM
Thanks for everybody's helping hand. I have learnt a lot in this post. :)