PDA

View Full Version : About participle phrases


jshin
08-20-2006, 06:34 PM
Please tell me the difference.

1. I sent a file to IBM listing cartons.
2. I sent a file listing cartons to IBM.
3. I sent a file to a warehouse listing cartons.

Thanks.

Heba
08-21-2006, 05:24 AM
I think it would be less ambiguous if you wrote it as:-

"I sent to IBM a file listing cartons."

Rusty
08-22-2006, 05:37 AM
Please tell me the difference.

1. I sent a file to IBM listing cartons.
2. I sent a file listing cartons to IBM.
3. I sent a file to a warehouse listing cartons.

Thanks.
Position determines importance. The more important phrase comes first.
1. I sent a file to IBM listing cartons.
2. I sent a file listing cartons to IBM.
3. I sent a file to a warehouse listing cartons. (This sentence is awkward. The distance between a file and its modifier, listing cartons, makes us wonder whether the file listed cartons or the warehouse listed cartons).